Harrowing memories of the Grenfell Tower fire shook attendees at the third and final day of the Hazards Process Safety Conference in Manchester.
Delivering the final plenary presentation of this year’s conference, Arup’s director of culture and strategy realisation Gill Kernick called on the need for “systemic change” after the 2017 fire in the West London tower block that killed 72 people.
The image of Grenfell is “seared on my soul,” said Kernic, who lived on the 21st floor of the tower until 2014 and watched the blaze from the balcony of a neighbouring block of flats. Seven of Kernick’s former immediate neighbours were killed in the fire.
Central to Kernick’s argument for systemic change was the need for everyone, including process safety engineers, to challenge the “power and norms” that exist in industry, and resist settling for just “piecemeal change”.
Since Grenfell, Kernick explained there have been some improvements to construction industry standards, such as the ban on flammable cladding materials – the primary technical cause of the 2017 fire – and the launch of a new building safety regulator. “But it would be difficult to argue there has been systemic change,” she said. Throughout the talk, Kernick lamented the “cause and effect, command and control thinking” that often follows a disaster. Instead, “we must embrace new ways to navigate the complex world that we face,” she urged.
“Challenging our assumptions about whose lives matter, about whose voices count, is central to our ability to learn.” She challenged the audience to “become troublemakers” and question the systemic norms and assumptions in industry.
Grenfell has “shattered” Kernick’s trust in organisations “to do the right thing” by acting in the interest of public safety. But it has “made me better at learning: less willing to assume, and more inclined to challenge and question”. She urged the audience to question whose knowledge and expertise is trusted and disregarded in engineering projects – and to remember the fate of Grenfell residents whose experience and concerns raised before the fire went ignored.
Kernick concluded her speech by instructing the audience: “Never forget that what you do matters.”
For Benjamin Dorrian-Clark, a senior consultant in process safety at SLR Consulting, the concluding message “reinforced why I got into this role”.
Before going to university, Dorrian-Clark knew he wanted to be an engineer, but was unsure of what field to pursue. Preparing applications around the time of the Deepwater Horizon disaster in 2011, he thought: “I want to stop these kinds of events from happening.”
He said: “I think there are a lot of individuals going out into industry without understanding the overall impacts that [their work] could have on people.” Dorrian-Clark said he will take some of the things he has learned at the conference to the “people who have gone straight from university to industry. They’ve obviously learned everything in university, which is fantastic, but actually having that emotional connection to real-life events is so important.”
Talking extensively about the need to always remember past tragedies, Kernick also mentioned the Aberfan disaster, the 60th anniversary of which was commemorated last month. “I think these types of events – Aberfan, Grenfell – reinforce that people need to be thinking about safety throughout the life cycle of whatever they’re doing,” Dorrian-Clark said.
“The way we learn and retain key technical information about process safety is through stories. And I think, unfortunately, it’s a tragedy what happened, but this story will be stuck in the minds of many people in years to come. We have to and we should learn from these things.”
Wrapping up the three-day conference, chair Eamon Chandler highlighted the quality of all five plenary speakers and encouraged attendees to take away actionable lessons. Kernick’s presentation, in particular, “highlights just how much we have to know about the people who are near to the hazard, and how we have to appreciate and listen to them”.
Catch up on the latest news, views and jobs from The Chemical Engineer. Below are the four latest issues. View a wider selection of the archive from within the Magazine section of this site.