Safety culture and human behaviour took centre stage at a packed second day of IChemE’s Hazards 36 Process Safety Conference.
Kicking off proceedings at Old Trafford Cricket Ground in Manchester was Richard Scaife, a chartered occupational psychologist selected to deliver one of this year’s plenary presentations. As director of the Keil Centre, a service providing psychological consultancy and support to industry and government, Scaife specialises in how human factors can be implemented into every stage of an accident investigation.
“I don’t have much hair left, and that is because I’ve torn most of it out,” Scaife lamented. The cause of his despair was the prevalence of news reports and widely publicised investigations into major accidents such as plane and train crashes that declare the “root cause” of the incident to have been a human or technical error – as opposed to the fundamental reasons why certain behaviours that led to the incident occurred.
Achieving the thoroughness an investigation requires to meaningfully learn from an incident requires reliable data, often entirely dependent on witness interviews. But corporate investigations can often have the effect of discouraging witnesses from speaking with candour, Scaife said, particularly if they are made to feel like their individual behaviour is under the spotlight.
“Having that psychologically safe culture and just culture that really encourages people to speak up” is vital, he urged.
The most important thing, Scaife said, is establishing the correct question to investigate. He used the example of a patient who died after contracting septicemia during an operation. The investigation, which initially asked “why did the patient die?”, failed to encourage operating theatre staff to speak openly, feeling that managers were trying to “pin the blame on someone”. Only when the scope changed to asking “why was bacteria in the operating theatre?” did witnesses open up, eventually uncovering more “systemic” reasons for the incident.
IChemE Fellow Michael Godfrey, also known as “that process safety guy” in his part-time consultancy work, said Scaife’s presentation was “absolutely spot on”. After nearly four decades in process safety, Godfrey particularly resonated with Scaife’s calls to resist pinning blame on individual operators and instead understand the circumstances of flawed behaviour. “You can’t blame the operator, you can’t sack the pilot for the accident. You’ve absolutely got to get to the root causes.”
The second plenary came from Nigel Cairns, a chartered engineer at insurance firm Liberty Specialty Markets, who discussed the recent major accident trends across refining, petrochemicals and gas plants noted by the onshore energy insurance industry.
Central to Cairns’ presentation was the “long-term dominance” of the US in business downtime, which has faced additional pressure caused by the increase in operations as a result of geopolitics. Even before the Strait of Hormuz closure prompted a ramp-up in oil and gas production outside the Middle East, “global refining margins had already doubled” from 2015 to 2026, Cairns noted. As a result of the Iran war, North American refining utilisation rates have “crept over 95% as a number of oil majors have postponed planned maintenance activities”.
Coupled with the war in Ukraine, “we have seen US refineries operating near maximum capacity for the longest sustained period this century”.
Another US-based issue, Cairns highlighted, is that often operators will not make improvements unless legally required to. “We can have a very frustrating time, particularly working in North America, where we might suggest an improvement that might make good sense and would pass a cost-benefit analysis, but the site is just not interested because they’re not required by OSHA [the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration] to do that.”
Wrapping things up, Hazards technical committee chair Eamon Chandler reflected on his fourth and final year in charge of the conference, which saw record attendance, saying this year’s conference “has been an order of magnitude better than four years ago”.
He added: “I think the plenary speakers have been really much more diverse than we’ve achieved in the past … I’ve always wanted to have another human factors speaker, and we got Richard this morning, who was very good. The fresh eyes look from the insurance broker [Cairns] was something different, and we’ve always wanted to do that.”
Committee member Ashley Hynds said he is always impressed by how practical the presentations at Hazards are to real-world engineering. “The things that you learn at Hazards are really applicable. It’s not just some concept that might work in 5-10 years’ time. It’s stuff that’s happening now.”
Catch up on the latest news, views and jobs from The Chemical Engineer. Below are the four latest issues. View a wider selection of the archive from within the Magazine section of this site.